Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 292
Listener-supported — Commercial-free
Comments (808)add comment
I saw Tull in concert for the 1972 Think as a Brick tour, an 18th birthday gift from my girlfriend (and later wife) at Memorial Collisium in Dallas. The opening act was The Eagles (yes, those Eagles). Amazing show! I saw them again several times over the years, as well as The Eagles.
lizardking wrote:
Yes....and only a second after 22 minutes of this glorious tune...I bumped by 7 to an 8....really now THIS is why RP kicks FM's ass...Long Live RP!!
Indeed. But in this age of short attention spans, this probably too much for the three minute, twitter toktokers
Yes....and only a second after 22 minutes of this glorious tune...I bumped by 7 to an 8....really now THIS is why RP kicks FM's ass...Long Live RP!!
Indeed. But in this age of short attention spans, this probably too much for the three minute, twitter toktokers
On of a kind- epic in every sense of the word
zapeta wrote:
Disagree. The worst thing that I have heard is Alice's Restaurant. This is genius!
Literally the worst thing played on RP.
Disagree. The worst thing that I have heard is Alice's Restaurant. This is genius!
Greyerwrit wrote:
Commenting to give this a lift to the top as well. When I stopped laughing.
Ya, scrolling lyrics, with coloured highlights like karaoke would be helpful. ;)
Commenting to give this a lift to the top as well. When I stopped laughing.
Ya, scrolling lyrics, with coloured highlights like karaoke would be helpful. ;)
Meh, still only a 10. Why don't the knob go to 11?
I gotta say RP can take an album with mediocre recording quality and make it shine! Hey look, there's a great bass line in Thick As A Brick! Jeffery Hammond kicks butt!
Off to the vinyl stash to play side 2 on this glorious Sunday morning.
-John
Off to the vinyl stash to play side 2 on this glorious Sunday morning.
-John
Well, I've got my first pick the next time I go out for karaoke.
Ugh. Just not a fan of Tull.
Many fond memories from a misspent youth listening to this and other album sides.
TDS513 wrote:
Yes. Yes, it is necessary.
Why is it so long???? Is it really necessary??
Yes. Yes, it is necessary.
There are so many comments on this section and I am honored to be part of it to make it from 797 to 798 comments.
but it is a reaalllllllllllllllllllllllllllly long song I have to be
to listen to this song
Why is it so long???? Is it really necessary??
Just finished listening.....what year is it now?!
maryte wrote:
Same here
oh it takes me back.
Ah, I do take perverse joy in the pain this magnificent tune seems to cause so many others! For me, it's utterly delightful, with memories of singing loudly from start to finish at some times, and falling asleep while listening with headphones on, moving to awareness every time the eight-track player *chunk-a-chunked* to the next track!
Same here
oh it takes me back.
I dislike brief, fleeting songs like these. Why be so lazy and not make it at least a bit longer?
(4 years after TAAB)
Posted 10 years ago by olivertwist:
Hannio wrote:The release date was more like 1971 or 72, I believe, not 1997. Maybe 1997 was when side one finally came to an end.
Had to bring this comment up to the top. This is the most entertaining comments section of any song on RP!
The comments are a whole other reason for Radio Paradise.
Hannio wrote:The release date was more like 1971 or 72, I believe, not 1997. Maybe 1997 was when side one finally came to an end.
Had to bring this comment up to the top. This is the most entertaining comments section of any song on RP!
The comments are a whole other reason for Radio Paradise.
rgio wrote:
Commenting to give this a lift to the top as well. When I stopped laughing.
Can you tell me where we are in the Lyrics?
Thanks
Commenting to give this a lift to the top as well. When I stopped laughing.
One of their finest works
yoksa wrote:
Same here, one of the best concerts i've been. Frankfurt 1987
I saw them in 1974 and they were mesmerising! The show is on my list of top five concerts and I have seen a few since! The album cover is framed and takes a rightful place among other greats hanging on the walls.
Same here, one of the best concerts i've been. Frankfurt 1987
So Jethro Tull, Mott the Hopple, Joe Cocker, and many others are not in the R&R Hall of Fame but Dolly Parton is? Something doesn't seem right to me.
Wow - first time I’ve heard this here - thanks BillG. And if we can go here, how about a little Gentle Giant?
yoksa wrote:
Eu os vi em 1989. Paixão à primeira vista.
I saw them in 1974 and they were mesmerising! The show is on my list of top five concerts and I have seen a few since! The album cover is framed and takes a rightful place among other greats hanging on the walls.
Eu os vi em 1989. Paixão à primeira vista.
Puro rock'n'roll
Excellent!
ProjectGemini07 wrote:
And what a master Ian is at it! Phenomenal!
Power flute!
Y’all haters should just be glad BillG is going easy on you and not spinning A Passion Play uncut. That’s when Tull really gets interesting.
WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thank you, Bill, for playing this WHOLE thing. It's a journey and a half. I appreciate your taking us along for this epic ride. I've heard this album and the cuts a thousand times but hearing it all in one block like this really is mind-opening and gives me a new appreciation for the music and Ian's vision.
I've been using JT as a model story for my young daughter about following your dreams (like playing flute as lead instrument in a rock band), so when this song came on, we listened to the flute parts with special interest.
I've been using JT as a model story for my young daughter about following your dreams (like playing flute as lead instrument in a rock band), so when this song came on, we listened to the flute parts with special interest.
Total Ratings: 2497Length: 22:00Plays (last 30 days):
Main Mix - 2
You need to remove the "s" from Plays and remove the brackets for a more accurate description. Thank you.
Thanks Bill, love it.
I saw them in 1974 and they were mesmerising! The show is on my list of top five concerts and I have seen a few since! The album cover is framed and takes a rightful place among other greats hanging on the walls.
Always love it when you play this album.
Terrific! Thanks Bill and Rebecca.
Another great song that captures the Counter Culture of the late 1960s, early 1970s.
Thanks Bill perfect start to my Monday morning!
Power flute!
Thanks Bill, yes rare play on RP but always enjoyable! Some of my best concerts memories, loved the film projection and first flown audio system I every saw! Changed concerts forever!


"Your sperm's in the gutter" ??
"he pees himself in the night" ??
Ian should have called this Thick as a Prick.
"he pees himself in the night" ??
Ian should have called this Thick as a Prick.
Hippostar wrote:
Actually that was just half of it. Side one.
Had never heard this entire piece before RP... I think I sat stunned and frozen, unable to do anything for 22 minutes. How did I miss this my entire life?
Actually that was just half of it. Side one.
might be a tad too long
Saw the L.A. concert when this came out and it was magical.
Don’t forget “A Passion Play”, I also love that one.
unclehud wrote:
Ellie Mae's brother.
He's probably listening to this down at the Seement pond.
Ellie Mae's brother.
He's probably listening to this down at the Seement pond.
Trip Hop, who knew?
mjbaumann wrote:
Bill warned you in the intro...I guess you are too stubborn to PSD. Go away now.
It's art, go with the flow.
Bill warned you in the intro...I guess you are too stubborn to PSD. Go away now.
It's art, go with the flow.
After more than 40 years of listening to Jethro Tull, they are by far still my favorite Prog Rock Bank.
m00n3east wrote:
Bill warned you in the intro...I guess you are too stubborn to PSD. Go away now.
OMG, will this s*** ever end?
Bill warned you in the intro...I guess you are too stubborn to PSD. Go away now.
beneggen wrote:
There is always Clear Channel
i really hate Jethro tull,
There is always Clear Channel
Bumping this up to a 7... naw, 8. I'm enjoying hanging around in this song.
Their concerts must have been something else. I can just imagine all the fans going out for breakfast between the final song and the encore.
Their concerts must have been something else. I can just imagine all the fans going out for breakfast between the final song and the encore.
Twenty minutes of Jethro Tull that nobody expected, and maybe didn't appreciate, but it brings me back to the days when radio was real, the DJs played what they wanted and our young minds were sent on a voyage of discovery. Thanks, RP for bringing that feeling back. I'm pledging another $20 bucks for that feeling. Keep it weird.
tlbritton wrote:
Ellie Mae's brother.
...but which one is Jethro? 

Ellie Mae's brother.
I'm not by any means a real Jethro Tull fan, but really appreciate the playing of an entire sets of connected songs as they were intended to be received. Muchas gracias
Was going to go to bed, but suppose I will delay that 22 minutes... Now, where is side 2?
aelfheld wrote:
"LITTLE MILTON IN SCHOOL-GIRL PREGNANCY ROW"
Always read below the fold.
Is it just me, or does Little Milton look like the kid on Two and a Half Men?
"LITTLE MILTON IN SCHOOL-GIRL PREGNANCY ROW"
Always read below the fold.
Is it just me, or does Little Milton look like the kid on Two and a Half Men?
rgio wrote:
"... the builder of the castles
renews the age-old purpose
and contemplates the milking girl
whose offer is his need."
Can you tell me where we are in the Lyrics?
Thanks
Thanks
"... the builder of the castles
renews the age-old purpose
and contemplates the milking girl
whose offer is his need."
Hippostar wrote:
Get the LP or CD. You've only heard half the "song."
Had never heard this entire piece before RP... I think I sat stunned and frozen, unable to do anything for 22 minutes. How did I miss this my entire life?
Get the LP or CD. You've only heard half the "song."
THIS ALBUM MADE ME SWOON. Still does.
How in the world could a rock and roll band make an orchestral piece that spanned the front AND back of an LP?!?!? Cheeky bastards! Ya-hoo-eee! Carry on!
I spent hours and hours reading the newspaper album cover.
How in the world could a rock and roll band make an orchestral piece that spanned the front AND back of an LP?!?!? Cheeky bastards! Ya-hoo-eee! Carry on!
I spent hours and hours reading the newspaper album cover.
Fantastic music, clear ten.
me: how many chords are in there?
jethro tull: yes.
jethro tull: yes.
The-never-ending song, my banana is tired!


Had never heard this entire piece before RP... I think I sat stunned and frozen, unable to do anything for 22 minutes. How did I miss this my entire life?
Nice bit of impenetrable Tull prog to smooth me into the afternoon.
Thanks RP.
Thanks RP.
Back in the days when there were live DJs on the radio (look it up, kids), when this version of this song came on, you knew the DJ was taking a smoke break.
Hi Rebecca, Bill, made my day! Haven't heard it for ages but see there! didn't forget a beat or a line
I Love it, don´t stop the music
I Love it, don´t stop the music beneggen wrote:
#metoo. What a terrible, soulless music. You really need to be a teenager or high on drugs (or both) to like it.
#metoo. What a terrible, soulless music. You really need to be a teenager or high on drugs (or both) to like it.
i really hate Jethro tull,
Wow! What a treat to hear all these Jethro Tull tunes! I've been a fan for decades and though I'm not a lover of some of the heavy rock stuff, it truly is music to my ears. I never hear it played here in Scotland.....
Thank you so much, RP!!!!.
Thank you so much, RP!!!!.

Great fun following the lyrics. Walk away for 10 seconds and spend another 2 minutes finding where you are in the song.
Awesome piece!
Awesome piece!
Critics hated it...but every 18 year old boy I knew (including me) wore out copy after copy -- but only side one.
All these years later it's still amazing.
All these years later it's still amazing.
The best thing about this song is that it makes me stop listening to RP for awhile and go down the rabbit hole of YouTube to find the stuff I love hearing on RP mostly to hear how the bands perform the songs live. My take on PSD. Listening to this is more like PTSD.
If the doctor told me I had six months to live, I would play this every day because it would seem like an eternity and I would welcome my demise. Might even get him to tell me I only have four months...
YES! Perfect 20 minute jam to push me through this last little bit of work before Thanksgiving. Volume up. Thanks Bill!
MiloD wrote:
I saw them in Jacksonville right after this came out. They played the first side, then Aqualung, then the second side. Even through the chemically induced haze it was spectacular!
Thanks Bill!
saw this concert in San Diego, would have been closer to 72, They were great!
;-{)
;-{)
I saw them in Jacksonville right after this came out. They played the first side, then Aqualung, then the second side. Even through the chemically induced haze it was spectacular!
Thanks Bill!
BillG could follow this with Tubular Bells and take an extra extra break.
Long Live RP and whole album side plays!
Long Live RP and whole album side plays!
So very good.
Ian and Marty always get the glory but each successive era of Tull was primarily defined by the ever changing roster of uniquely different keyboardists. John Evans brought a wonderful sense of pomp and circus stance (not a typo) to this era.
Ian and Marty always get the glory but each successive era of Tull was primarily defined by the ever changing roster of uniquely different keyboardists. John Evans brought a wonderful sense of pomp and circus stance (not a typo) to this era.
This is a brilliant piece of music, and so 70's -- wild, crazy, artistic,and entertaining. Definitely not in the 3:30 And No Longer slot. Love it. RP, don't ever change. 

How long would it have been if not restricted to an LP side? olivertwist wrote:
Had to bring this comment up to the top. This is the most entertaining comments section of any song on RP!
Had to bring this comment up to the top. This is the most entertaining comments section of any song on RP!
Can you tell me where we are in the Lyrics?
Thanks
Thanks
Remembering all the Tull shows at the Chicago Stadium. Every new album sprung another tour, and then some. Memories.
This reminds me of Wagner, that rarely resolves. I don't like Wagner much either.
saw this concert in San Diego, would have been closer to 72, They were great!
;-{)
;-{)
I guess that those who rate this song a 1 , are rating 8 at Jolene/Dolly Parton !!!!!
This show was awesome. It was the best new music on those days.
This show was awesome. It was the best new music on those days.
I must admit my 10 rating was probably nostalgic. But I’ve Now just realised RP is playing the whole side . That takes this to a different level of comment - 10 rating just for the balls to do so...
Ahhhh. Back when RnR was creative, pushing the envelope, exploring new musical and lyrical concepts.
And this song is one album side!
And what the heck does "thick as a brick" mean? It means the best time ever for RnR!
And this song is one album side!
And what the heck does "thick as a brick" mean? It means the best time ever for RnR!
olivertwist wrote:
Had to bring this comment up to the top. This is the most entertaining comments section of any song on RP!
Had to bring this comment up to the top. This is the most entertaining comments section of any song on RP!
Radio Paradise answering the question, "How much prog-rock flute is TOO MUCH prog-rock flute?"
"Feel Free to use PSD" is the funniest thing I've heard Bill say.
Not a Tull Fan but that made me listen.
Not a Tull Fan but that made me listen.
As me County Mayo friend Mick (yes, really) used to say "Tick as Brick is brillyant"
And I agreed.
And I agreed.
amyliana44 wrote:
It's amazing when you listen after thirty years and realise that you recall not only all the words, but all the instrumentation, breaks, stops/starts, dynamics, everything. And it isn't exactly repetitive.
Bill prefaced today's playing of Side 1 with "Here's something for Jethro Tull fans... hardcore Jethro Tull fans." At first I didn't think that he was talking about me, but then again I do remember almost every word of side 1. That suggests the many many hours I spent in my youth listening to this. Haven't listened to it more than 3 or 4 times since high school. I still remember the party in 1982 or so when I first heard it. So yeah, I guess I qualify. I was so happy to get to hear more than the short version today.
It's amazing when you listen after thirty years and realise that you recall not only all the words, but all the instrumentation, breaks, stops/starts, dynamics, everything. And it isn't exactly repetitive.
Oh yes, formative years stuff!
I was a teenager in the early eighties, and scoured record libraries, family friends' record collections, second-hand record shops, *anything* for something more interesting than the prevailing music of the time. That's where I discovered Jethro Tull (+ other prog & space rock) - this album was one of my favourites.
I still enjoy listening to it now, even though I probably wouldn't choose to play it specifically.
I was a teenager in the early eighties, and scoured record libraries, family friends' record collections, second-hand record shops, *anything* for something more interesting than the prevailing music of the time. That's where I discovered Jethro Tull (+ other prog & space rock) - this album was one of my favourites.
I still enjoy listening to it now, even though I probably wouldn't choose to play it specifically.
Sitting here at my desk thinking, 'Geez, does this song ever end?' Apparently yes, after 22 minutes exactly...
Did we ever conquer RIDO?
(Still have the LP with the full newspaper.)
(Still have the LP with the full newspaper.)
This is genius.
idiot_wind wrote:
"LITTLE MILTON IN SCHOOL-GIRL PREGNANCY ROW"
Always read below the fold.
And let us not forget that little Milton (see newspaper) got screwed out of winning, due to a rumpus!
How cheeky!
How cheeky!
"LITTLE MILTON IN SCHOOL-GIRL PREGNANCY ROW"
Always read below the fold.
Ericocean you're putting the good name Eric to shame. *smile* Both Joni and Tull are totally worth full album visits.
I got introduced to Tull in 71 with the release of Aqualung - I was 11. I own all but the last two releases, have seen them 14 times, and if it wasn't for Ian's voice being shot would still go. Pity he can't just rescore for a lower range or produce a few more instrumental albums - his Divinities (12 Dances with God) album is indeed divine. That I'd award a 12.
Nice intro Bill... lets see where are those headphones?
If you’re a JT fan check out the remastered release of "This Was"
Original album and bonus tracks remixed in stereo by Steven WilsonLive BBC sessions recorded in 1968
Original mono mix and original 1968 U.K. stereo mixOriginal album and bonus tracks remixed by Steven Wilson in 4.1 DTS and AC3 Dolby Digital surround and 96/24 LPCM stereo
Flat transfer of the 1968 stereo remixPresented in a case-bound DVD book filled with an extensive history of the album, track-by-track annotations by Ian Anderson, plus rare and unseen photographs
JT was the first show I saw and listened to a "flying" PA system. that changed my world!!!
Original album and bonus tracks remixed in stereo by Steven WilsonLive BBC sessions recorded in 1968
Original mono mix and original 1968 U.K. stereo mixOriginal album and bonus tracks remixed by Steven Wilson in 4.1 DTS and AC3 Dolby Digital surround and 96/24 LPCM stereo
Flat transfer of the 1968 stereo remixPresented in a case-bound DVD book filled with an extensive history of the album, track-by-track annotations by Ian Anderson, plus rare and unseen photographs
JT was the first show I saw and listened to a "flying" PA system. that changed my world!!!
That is a great version, thanks!
And let us not forget that little Milton (see newspaper) got screwed out of winning, due to a rumpus!
How cheeky!
How cheeky!
Thanks Bill for not being like everyone else!
Thank you for playing this masterpiece. Not to everyone's taste, but for me an absolute 10.
Gosh, I hope you play a whole side of a Joni Mitchell album next. Then we can compare notes on which induces more human suffering, this or that.
What a lovely, strange, cryptic, hooky, crazy song. Ahhhh, the way RnR use to be!
MattRudely wrote:

Took a lot shorter time to invent the seed drill. 
(I like it.)

(I like it.)
Brilliant! Then and now. Thanks Bill
Prog rock + flutes = still the worst.
I get that some people love Jethro Tull and for those people, Bill should be applauded for playing a diverse array of music.
I'm downgrading my 3 rating to a 2 and moving on to the next song, though.
I get that some people love Jethro Tull and for those people, Bill should be applauded for playing a diverse array of music.
I'm downgrading my 3 rating to a 2 and moving on to the next song, though.
Or the opposite direction Bill? HAHA.... I love this tune. Thank you!
My first album. It was the mid 70s.
Ive moved on.
After Roxy and Tull in the same morning I couldn’t stay on the sidelines any more
Bill prefaced today's playing of Side 1 with "Here's something for Jethro Tull fans... hardcore Jethro Tull fans." At first I didn't think that he was talking about me, but then again I do remember almost every word of side 1. That suggests the many many hours I spent in my youth listening to this. Haven't listened to it more than 3 or 4 times since high school. I still remember the party in 1982 or so when I first heard it. So yeah, I guess I qualify. I was so happy to get to hear more than the short version today.
This still remains an outstanding achievement - thanks for playing the entire first side!
Bands of the late 60s, 70s and 80s had distinguishing features. Led Zeppelin, ELP, Deep Purple, Jethro Tull immediately reconized not like today
Ah, take a me back to wearing out this album on my Aiwa cassette boom box back when this was released. my first comment.
Literally the worst thing played on RP.
Took a lot shorter time to invent the seed drill. 
(I like it.)

(I like it.)
Was just about to head for bed, then this comes on. I'm jamming now! 
8 down to 3
Canadese wrote:
That is the name of the band presumably named after the original Jethro Tull.....
Jethro Tull. (born 1674, Basildon, Berkshire, Eng.—died Feb. 21, 1741, Prosperous Farm, near Hungerford, Berkshire), English agronomist, agriculturist, writer, and inventor whose ideas helped form the basis of modern British agriculture. Tull trained for the bar, to which he was called in 1699.
I was just joshin' however I have heard this question asked before! Interesting history on the presumption of the origin of the band's name.
That is the name of the band presumably named after the original Jethro Tull.....
Jethro Tull. (born 1674, Basildon, Berkshire, Eng.—died Feb. 21, 1741, Prosperous Farm, near Hungerford, Berkshire), English agronomist, agriculturist, writer, and inventor whose ideas helped form the basis of modern British agriculture. Tull trained for the bar, to which he was called in 1699.
I was just joshin' however I have heard this question asked before! Interesting history on the presumption of the origin of the band's name.



